Migrating from Legacy Systems

OpenTAP vs TofuPilot : comparatif séquenceurs

Comparez OpenTAP de Keysight et le framework TofuPilot : langage, plans de test, licences, stockage des résultats et déploiement.

JJulien Buteau
intermediate8 min de lecture9 novembre 2026

OpenTAP is an open-source test sequencer for .NET, developed and maintained by Keysight under the MPL 2.0 license. Its commercial edition is Keysight PathWave Test Automation. The TofuPilot Framework is an open-source Python test framework with a Rust execution engine, under the MIT license, connected to the TofuPilot dashboard. This guide compares them for production test.

Facts about OpenTAP were checked against its repository, opentap.io and Keysight's product pages in November 2026 (OpenTAP 9.35).

Overview

OpenTAPTofuPilot Framework
MaintainerKeysightTofuPilot
LicenseMPL 2.0 (plugins may stay proprietary)MIT
LanguageC# / .NET (Python through a Python.NET plugin)Python (Rust engine)
Test definitionTest plan built from TestStep plugins in an editorYAML procedure, Python phases and plugs
CLItaptofupilot
EditorsKeysight GUI editor, open-source TUI editorAny text editor, Git
Commercial editionPathWave Test Automation (KS8400B developer, KS8000B deployment)TofuPilot plans (Lab, Pro, Enterprise)
PlatformsWindows x86, Linux x86, macOS Apple silicon, DockerWindows, Linux, macOS

Licensing

OpenTAP's core is free. Since version 9.29, Keysight's GUI editor is also available under a no-cost Community License, which requires an OpenTAP account, an internet connection and opt-in telemetry on system info, plugins, execution statistics, DUTs and instruments, with no support or warranty. Commercial support, the developer tools (Results Viewer, Timing Analyzer) and deployment licenses come with PathWave Test Automation, priced on quote, node-locked, transportable or floating.

The TofuPilot Framework and CLI are free and run without an account. The dashboard, fleet deployment and analytics come with a TofuPilot plan, hosted or self-hosted.

The Same Test in Both

A 3.3 V rail check judged against 3.2 V to 3.4 V.

OpenTAP Version

A test step is a C# class. The step publishes its result and sets its verdict.

RailCheck.cs
// OpenTAP test step: read the rail, publish it, set the verdict.[Display("Rail 3V3", Description = "Measure the 3.3 V rail")]public class RailCheck : TestStep{    public Multimeter Dmm { get; set; }    public override void Run()    {        double volts = Dmm.ReadVoltage();        Results.Publish("Rail", new List<string> { "Volts" }, volts);        UpgradeVerdict(volts >= 3.2 && volts <= 3.4 ? Verdict.Pass : Verdict.Fail);    }}

The step is compiled into a plugin, then added to a test plan (.TapPlan) in the editor.

TofuPilot Framework Version

procedure.yaml
19 lines
name: Power Checkversion: 1.0.0plugs:  - name: Multimeter    key: dmm    python: plugs.dmm:Multimetermain:  - name: Rail 3V3    key: rail_3v3    python: phases.rail_3v3    measurements:      - name: Rail 3V3        key: rail_3v3        unit: V        validators:          - {operator: ">=", expected_value: 3.2}          - {operator: "<=", expected_value: 3.4}
phases/rail_3v3.py
def rail_3v3(measurements, dmm):    measurements.rail_3v3 = dmm.read_voltage()

The limits are data in the procedure, not branches in code, so the dashboard stores them with each value and plots margins over time.

Feature Comparison

FeatureOpenTAPTofuPilot Framework
Limits as dataNo, verdict set in step codeYes, YAML validators
Parallel executionYes (parallel step)Yes (parallel phases)
Multi-slot fixturesThrough test plan designYes, built in
Instrument pluginsPackage repository, SCPI plugin, Keysight driversPlugs wrapping PyVISA or any Python driver
Operator UIEditor or custom panel (deployment system)Browser kiosk declared in the procedure
Result storageResultListener plugins: CSV, text log, SQLite, PostgreSQLStation queue, uploaded to the dashboard
AnalyticsDesktop tools in the paid developer editionYield, control charts and Cpk in the dashboard
Fleet deploymentDeployment license per station, central push not documentedGit push to every linked station, instant rollback
Version controlTest plans are XML filesYAML and Python, diff friendly

When to Use OpenTAP

  • The team writes C# and runs on .NET.
  • Most instruments are Keysight, with plugins already available.
  • Commercial support from the instrument vendor is a requirement.
  • Engineers prefer building test plans in a GUI editor.

When to Use the TofuPilot Framework

  • The team writes Python and wants the test plan as reviewable text in Git.
  • Limits must be stored with every value for traceability and SPC.
  • Several stations run the same procedure, deployed and rolled back centrally.
  • Operators need guided forms without building a custom panel.
  • Analytics must cover every station without desktop tools.

Using OpenTAP with TofuPilot

OpenTAP results reach other systems through ResultListener plugins. A listener built on the TofuPilot C# SDK can upload each run to the dashboard, which keeps existing test plans and adds fleet analytics. See the SDK documentation.

For a wider comparison including TestStand, OpenHTF and pytest, see Manufacturing Test Frameworks Compared.

Plus de guides

Mettez ce guide en pratique